Site logo

The Cult of Saints in Late Antiquity


from its origins to circa AD 700, across the entire Christian world


Hilary of Arles writes the Sermon on the Life of Saint *Honoratus (founder of Lérins and bishop of Arles, ob. 429/430) in Latin at Arles (southern Gaul), 430/431. Overview entry.

Evidence ID

E06026

Type of Evidence

Literary - Sermons/Homilies

Literary - Hagiographical - Lives

Hilary of Arles, Sermon on the Life of Saint Honoratus (Sermo de vita sancti Honorati, BHL 3975, CPL 501).

Summary:

(1.) Hilary begins by stating that this is the day when Honoratus laid aside his body (corpore exutus est). (2-3.) He insists that no one can describe Honoratus’ virtues adequately, least of all somebody of his own limited ability.

(4.) How Honoratus was born into a family that enjoyed the highest secular honours, including the consulship. (5-6.) He is deeply pious from his childhood onwards, even though his family are worldly and uninterested in religion. His father resists his devotion to religion and tries to tempt him away from it. (7.) Hilary imagines a soliloquy by Honoratus, in which he determines to separate himself from the world. (8.) Honoratus commits himself fully to religion, adopting ascetic garb and fasting. His family persecute him. (9.) Honoratus’ older brother converts to asceticism under his influence. They compete in their renunciations and the extent of their devotion.

(10.) As their reputation for holiness spreads they wish to flee glory. (11.) They decide to leave their homeland, and do so against the resistance of their family, selling their property. (12.) They have as their mentor an old man (senex), Caprasius, who 'is still living an angelic life on the islands' (angelica adhuc in insulis conversatione degentem). (13.) [A passage rejected as an interpolation in the standard critical edition by Cavallin, but admitted in most other editions, claims that while they were passing through Marseille, the bishop tried to persuade Honoratus to join the clergy there.] (14.) They travel by sea to Achaea, where Honoratus’ brother Venantius [named for the first time] dies at the town of Mothone. The townspeople of all languages and religions, including the Jews, lament at his funeral.

(15.) Honoratus travels back to Gaul through Italy, seeking a wilderness (heremus) where he can settle. Near the Alps he discovers an island, uninhabited because it was thickly overgrown and full of poisonous animals. It is located in the see of the holy bishop Leontius [of Fréjus]. When Honoratus takes possession of the island, the poisonous serpents flee (see E06073). (16.) Honoratus establishes a fortress of God in a place that had previously repelled people. He accepts ordination as a presbyter, but maintains the humility of a monk. (17.) Through his industry a church and dwelling places are built. He miraculously brings forth a spring of fresh water (see E06073). (17-19.) Those who sought Christ flocked to Honoratus. Every land had citizens in his monastery. Honoratus transformed the character of those who joined the community, finding exactly the right way to approach each person, offering discipline or comfort as necessary, and constantly observing and thinking about every member of the community. They in turn came to feel as Honoratus did, suffering or rejoicing along with him.

(20-21.) He always showed the greatest hospitality to those who visited the island. Everything he received from others he gave away for purposes such as redeeming captives. On one occasion he gave the last coin in the treasury (arca) to a poor man, reassuring those with him that what he had given away would soon be replenished. Only a few hours later someone arrived with a new gift that proved this true. Whoever came to him in difficulties of any kind almost always went away with those difficulties solved. (22.) Honoratus corresponded with many people in letters of extraordinary eloquence. He exchanged letters written on wax tablets with Eucherius on the next island [the later bishop of Lyon (ob. c. 451), then head of a neighbouring ascetic community].

(23-4.) Honoratus travels back to his family home to persuade his young relative Hilary to adopt a religious life. He passionately exhorts Hilary, who is too attached to the world to respond. But when he prays for Hilary, God brings about Hilary's conversion. Honoratus takes Hilary back with him to the monastery and instructs him.

(25.) Hilary tells his audience that up till now he has spoken of things known to others rather than them. But they all saw Honoratus as bishop. Why did they choose as their bishop an unknown man from a distant monastery, orphaning his flock there? God, who dispenses all things, led Honoratus across land and sea to benefit them. (26-7.) During the brief time he was with them they themselves witnessed in Honoratus all the qualities that he has just described. He showed the same concern for his flock and the same discernment of individuals that he had in the monastery. (28.) When he became a bishop, his first concern was to establish harmony in a church that had been divided by disputes over the episcopal succession. As he had done in the monastery, he used the wealth of the church for charity.

(29.) Honoratus continues working and preaching even in his final illness. He preaches for the last time on the feast of epiphany. His death is not from disease, but from long infirmity caused by his renunciations and exacerbated by his refusal to accept any relief. He dies on the eighth or ninth day after epiphany [this seeming uncertainty probably indicates that he died around midnight], having continued his work as bishop until only four days earlier. (30.) On his deathbed, he consoles those around him, and carefully puts in order his own affairs and those of the church. (31.) Hilary recalls some of his own conversations with Honoratus at this time. (32.) Honoratus admonishes the powerful men who visit him, including the Praetorian Prefect, using his approaching death as an example of the transience of power and wealth. (33.) Hilary describes Honoratus' last words to his friends and to members of the community he had assembled around him. (34.) Honoratus dies. Many people are woken from their sleep by visions of him being received by the saints. Even though Honoratus died in the middle of the night, a crowd spontaneously gathers to meet his body when it is brought to the church (see E06097). Hilary tells his audience that they remember these things more vividly than he can describe them. (35.) Honoratus' funeral. The vestments on his body are torn to shreds by those seeking relics (see E00727). The presence of Honoratus' tomb gives confidence that he will be the city's patron in heaven.

(36.) God has granted to Hilary that he should live near Honoratus' tomb, and will grant to the congregation's prayers that he does not stray from Honoratus' path. Through Honoratus, God prepared Hilary to serve as their bishop. (37.) Honoratus' merits did not need to be proved by signs: his life was a perpetual sign. Hilary states that he believes it was granted to Honoratus' prayers that his spiritual power (virtutem) should not be displayed by signs (signa) (see E06098). Honoratus perpetually bore witness to Christ with his body, reducing his strength by fasting, while always fleeing excess and the desire for glory. (38.) His devotion to Christ extended even to his sleep, when he would still pour out words of exhortation and prayer. He often dreamed of being martyred (see E06099). (39.) Hilary concludes by asking Honoratus to remember his flock and to be their patron (patronus) and the interpreter and assertor of the prayers they pour out at his tomb.


Text: Cavallin 1952.
Summary: David Lambert.

Cult Places

Burial site of a saint - tomb/grave

Non Liturgical Activity

Composing and translating saint-related texts

Miracles

Miracle during lifetime
Power over elements (fire, earthquakes, floods, weather)
Miracle with animals and plants
Apparition, vision, dream, revelation
Observed scarcity/absence of miracles

Relics

Contact relic - saint’s possession and clothes

Protagonists in Cult and Narratives

Ecclesiastics - abbots
Ecclesiastics - bishops

Theorising on Sanctity

Considerations about the nature of miracles

Source

The Sermon on the Life of Honoratus opens with a declaration that it was delivered on the anniversary of Honoratus’ death (§ 1). Honoratus (PCBE 4, 'Honoratus 1'), who died in 429 or 430, is chiefly notable as the founder and first abbot of the monastic community of Lérins, but became bishop of Arles two years before his death. The author of the Sermon was Hilary (401-449), Honoratus' successor as bishop, who was also his relative and had been his protégé at both Lérins and Arles (PCBE 4, 'Hilarius 3'). The character of the text as an address to Honoratus’ congregation is emphasised throughout, with regular references to their presence and invocations of their recent memories of Honoratus. We have no way of knowing how far the extant text may have been revised from what was originally delivered: at about 7,000 words it is much longer than most surviving ancient sermons (though not too long for oral delivery), and contains features that may only have been appreciated by reading the text, such as the use of literary allusion (e.g. reminiscences in Hilary's account of his own conversion of Augustine's conversion scene in the Confessions, demonstrated by Courcelle 1968, 402-6). There is no doubt, however, that the Sermon was composed relatively soon after Honoratus’ death.

Evidence of the
Sermon’s reception appears almost immediately: the Eusebius Gallicanus sermon on Honoratus (E00781), probably dating from the 430s, contains passages which appear to respond to it (see E00851, E00724). Later in the 5th century, it was cited explicitly and used as a source by the author of the Life of Hilary (E06072). In the 7th century, it was quoted in the Life of Rusticula, a female monastic leader from Arles (E06492), so closely that the quotations can be used to help establish the text of the original (cf. Dolbeau 1981, 194). For an overview of subsequent evidence for the work’s circulation, see Valentin 1977, 41-3.

Manuscripts and editions
There are at least 36 manuscripts of the Sermon, of which 24 are listed in BHLms (bhlms.fltr.ucl.ac.be). On the manuscripts, see Cavallin 1952, 17-31; Valentin 1977, 43-57; Dolbeau 1981; Bouhot 1982. The oldest is Chartres, Bibliothèque municipale 5 (16), fol. 167r-177r (8th c.), originally from St Denis; this was seriously damaged in 1944 when the library at Chartres was hit by an incendiary bomb and only partly survives.

The editor of the standard modern edition, Samuel Cavallin, divided the manuscripts into four groups: an early variant represented solely by the Chartres manuscript, the manuscripts of a Cistercian calendar of saints’ lives which includes the
Sermon (the largest group numerically), and two groups originating from places with an institutional connection to Honoratus, Arles and Lérins. The Lérins manuscripts are all now lost, but lie behind the earliest printed editions. It should be noted that since Lérins was refounded in the 11th century after being abandoned, its manuscripts do not necessarily have any claim to great authority, and in fact Cavallin regarded them as being relatively insignificant in establishing the text.

The
Sermon was first printed in 1576 by the Counter-Reformation hagiographer Laurentius Surius, based on a manuscript from Lérins. After further editions in the late 16th and early 17th centuries (see below), also based on Lérins manuscripts, in 1643 the Sermon was edited by Jean Bolland for the Acta Sanctorum. Bolland’s text was based on a collation of Surius and another early printed edition with two manuscripts from the Cistercian branch of the tradition (Bolland 1643, 16; Cavallin 1952, 18-19). Various other editions were published in the 17th and 18th centuries; one of these, by Giacomo and Pietro Ballerini (Venice, 1756), was reprinted in Migne’s Patrologia Latina (PL 50, 1249-72).

The first modern critical edition of the
Sermon was published in 1952 by the Swedish scholar Samuel Cavallin, together with an edition of the Life of Hilary. A new edition, with a French translation, was produced in 1977 by Marie-Denise Valentin for Sources Chrétiennes. Valentin differed significantly from Cavallin in her interpretation of the manuscript tradition, deliberately privileging the Lérins branch as likely to be the most authoritative (Valentin 1977, 43-57); however, critics generally saw her approach as a misinterpretation of the manuscript evidence (see Dolbeau 1981, Bouhot 1982), and Cavallin’s remains the preferred scholarly edition.


Discussion

Any assessment of the Sermon on the Life of Honoratus as a source for Honoratus’ life and the beginnings of his cult has to start from the fact that it is a commemorative speech, not a systematic Life. In many ways it follows the pattern of a classical panegyric rather than what would become the norm in Lives of the saints (for discussion of various aspects of its literary character, see Consolino 1981; Weiss 1984; Gioanni 2010; Lambert 2013; Natal 2015).

The
Sermon is highly selective in its treatment of Honoratus’ life, with only three aspects treated at length: his early life and conversion (§§ 1-14), the foundation of Lérins and Honoratus’ leadership there (§§ 15-22, followed by a digression on Hilary’s own conversion at §§ 23-4), and Honoratus’ death and funeral (§§ 29-35). Strikingly for the Life of an episcopal saint, it says almost nothing about Honoratus’ activities as bishop of Arles: the brief treatment (§§ 25-8) does little more than state, without specific detail, that he showed the same virtues there that he had at Lérins. Hilary himself suggests (§ 26) that Honoratus’ time as bishop was too vivid a memory for his audience to need to be reminded of it. Given that Honoratus was bishop for only around two years, there is no doubt an element of truth in this, but it is also the case that the see of Arles in the 420s was enmeshed in both political and doctrinal conflicts (barely alluded to at § 28) which Hilary evidently preferred to pass over in silence.

There were other difficult issues which Hilary had to navigate when composing his sermon. One was his own position as bishop of Arles, an office he had just assumed at an extremely young age (around 28), to all appearances solely because he was Honoratus’ protégé and chosen successor. Securing Honoratus’ posthumous authority was therefore necessary to consolidate his own position (on this, see Natal 2015). Another was his relationship with Lérins, which he had left to join Honoratus in Arles, a move that some members of the community clearly disapproved of (see Leyser 1999, 195-201). From the point of view of the cult of saints, however, two particular issues stand out: miracles as a criterion for sanctity, and Honoratus’ relics and tomb. In relation to the miraculous, there is an obvious contrast between the depiction of Honoratus in the
Sermon and the only existing Gallic model for the depiction of a charismatic holy man, Martin of Tours in the works of Sulpicius Severus. For the way in which Hilary dealt with this, see E06073 and E06098. As regards relics and the importance for a civic community in possessing the tomb of a saint, the account in the Sermon of Honoratus’ funeral (E00727) is a key testimony to the ways in which these had already become central to Christian communal life in Gaul.


Bibliography

Editions:
Valentin, M.-D., Hilaire d'Arles, Vie de saint Honorat (Sources Chrétiennes 235; Paris, 1977), with annotated French translation.

Cavallin, S.,
Vitae sanctorum Honorati et Hilarii episcoporum Arelatensium (Lund, 1952), 49-78.

Migne, J.-P.,
Patrologia Latina 50 (Paris, 1846), 1249-1272. Reprint of Ballerini edition.

Ballerini, G. and P.,
S. Leonis Magni Opera, vol. II (Venice, 1756), 347-370.

Bolland, J.,
Acta Sanctorum, Jan. II (Antwerp, 1643), 17-24.

Barralis, V.,
Chronologia Sanctorum & aliorum virorum illustrium ac Abbatum Sacrae Insulae Lerinensis (Lyon, 1613), 1-15.

Genebrard, G.,
D. Hilarii Arelatensis episcopi de S. Honorato oratio funebris et D. Eucherii Lugdunensis episcopi de laudibus eremi. Nunc primum e Lerinensi bibliotheca producti (Paris, 1578).

Surius, L.,
De probatis sanctorum historiis, vol. I (Cologne, 1576), 370-81. Editio princeps.

Translations:
Deferrari, R.J.,
Early Christian Biographies (Fathers of the Church 15; Washington DC, 1952), 361-394. Based on PL edition.

Hoare, F.R.,
The Western Fathers (London, 1954), 248-280. Based on PL edition.

Labrousse, M.,
Saint Honorat. Fondateur de Lérins et évêque d'Arles (Bellefontaine, 1995). Annotated French translation; based on Cavallin's edition.

Further reading:
Bouhot, J.P., "Le texte du Sermo de uita sancti Honorati," Revue d'études augustiniennes et patristiques 28 (1982), 133-147.

Consolino, F.E., "Fra biografia e confessio: la forma letteraria del Sermo de vita S. Honorati di Ilario di Arles,"
Orpheus n.s. 2 (1981), 170-182.

Courcelle, P., "Nouveaux aspects de la culture lérinienne,"
Revue des études latines 46 (1968), 379–409.

Dolbeau, F., Review of Valentin 1977,
Revue d'études augustiniennes et patristiques 27 (1981), 193-195.

Gioanni, S., "La culture profane et la littérature monastique en Occident: l'exemple des ascètes provençaux (Ve-VIe siècles)," in: E. Rebillard and C. Sotinel (eds.), Les frontières du profane dans l'antiquité tardive (Rome, 2010), 177-195.

Labrousse, M., et al.,
Histoire de l'abbaye de Lérins (Bellefontaine, 2005).

Lambert, D., "Hilary of Arles," in: K. Pollmann and W. Otten (eds.),
The Oxford Guide to the Historical Reception of Augustine (Oxford, 2013), vol. 2, 1139-1140.

Leyser, C.,
"'This Sainted Isle': Panegyric, Nostalgia, and the Invention of Lerinian Monasticism," in: W. Klingshirn and M. Vessey (eds.), The Limits of Ancient Christianity: Essays on Late Antique Thought and Culture in Honor of R. A. Markus (Ann Arbor, 1999), 188-206.

Natal, D., "A Suitable Successor: Building Legitimacy in Hilary's
Sermon on the Life of Honoratus," Reti Medievali Rivista 16:1 (2015), 147-168.

Ripart, L.,
Les déserts de l’Occident. Genèse des lieux monastiques dans le sud-est de la Gaule (fin IVe - milieu VIe siècle) (Turnhout, 2021).

Weiss, J.-P., "Honorat héros antique et saint chrétien. Étude du mot
gratia dans la Vie de saint Honorat d'Hilaire d'Arles," Augustinianum 24 (1984), 265-280.


Record Created By

David Lambert

Date of Entry

10/03/2023

Related Saint Records
IDNameName in SourceIdentity
S00438Honoratus, founder of Lérins and bishop of Arles, ob. 429/30HonoratusCertain


Please quote this record referring to its author, database name, number, and, if possible, stable URL:
David Lambert, Cult of Saints, E06026 - http://csla.history.ox.ac.uk/record.php?recid=E06026